Follow Us:

Cast

Creative Team

Meet the Company

ADELYN RENALDO

<i>Performer</i>

Adelyn is delighted to be part of Lost in Love, sharing her love of storytelling through music. Her notable roles include Chip (Beauty and the Beast), Gary (The SpongeBob Musical), Amanda Thripp (Matilda), Buttons (Newsies), Tiny Tim and Fan Scrooge (A Christmas Carol), Shawanda (Elf Jr.), the unforgettable Deadite Baby (The Evil Dead), and Dormouse/Thrilla Caterpilla (Alice in Wonderland)— a collection of characters as imaginative as they are memorable.

An aspiring author, Adelyn brings creativity and heart to everything she does, both on stage and on the page. She is excited to reprise her role as Amanda Thripp this April in her school’s production of Matilda Jr., a character she loves returning to.

Adelyn lovingly dedicates this performance to her family and her best friend, Brooklynn, whose support and friendship mean the world to her.

ANDRIK SLOTA

<i>Performer</i>

Andrik is thrilled to be part of Lost in Love, celebrating music, connection, and all the different ways love shows up in our lives. Having enjoyed every Drama Geek Studios production he’s been part of so far, Andrik especially loved performing in Jesus Christ Superstar and Alice in Wonderland, Jr.

This marks Andrik’s 7th show with Drama Geek Studios, a place he proudly considers home. He’s also excited to take the stage in his school’s upcoming production of Willy Wonka this April — a sweet adventure he can’t wait to begin!

Andrik lovingly dedicates this performance to his family, whose unwavering support makes chasing his dreams possible every day.

DENISE CLARKE

<i>Performer</i>

Denise is thrilled to be part of Lost in Love, celebrating music, romance, and resilience through song. She previously appeared in the ensemble of Rock of Ages and is excited to return to the stage for this love-filled cabaret.

A fun fact about Denise: she loves to yodel, bringing a unique and playful energy to her performances. Offstage, she’s also DJ Denise with Distinctive Entertainment — available at distinctiveentinfo@gmail.com or on Facebook at DEntertainment.

Denise dedicates her entire performance to herself — for always facing challenges head-on — and to her kids, who are her greatest reason to rise and shine every day.

DREW RENALDO

<i>Performer</i>

Drew has spent years exploring every corner of the stage — from the bold comedy of Edna Turnblad (Hairspray) and LeFou (Beauty and the Beast), to the emotional depth of Dale Harding (One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest) and Annas (Jesus Christ Superstar), to writing and directing last spring's original adaptation of Alice in Wonderland. In addition to performing, Drew is also a published poet, always chasing stories that speak to the heart.

For Lost in Love, Drew dedicates this performance — as he always does — to the memory of his late father and uncle, whose love continue to guide him. He also dedicates it to the love of his life, his wonderful better half Kelly, and to their two beautiful children, Noah and Adelyn, with whom he is endlessly grateful to share both life and the stage.

JAMIE LeMELLEDO

<i>Performer</i>

Jamie is thrilled to be part of Lost in Love, lending her voice to an evening devoted entirely to matters of the heart. Her notable roles include Grease in her high school days, ensemble in Rock of Ages, and Electric Skate in The SpongeBob Musical.

Though she may not always wear her heart on her sleeve, Jamie has a secret: she’s actually a hopeless romantic, which makes her a perfect fit for this Valentine’s celebration. Outside of the theatre, Jamie is also the creative eye behind Jamie Lynn Photography, capturing moments filled with love and light.

Jamie dedicates this performance to her future husband — if one even exists, with hope, humor, and just a little faith.

JODI HRYHOR

<i>Performer</i>

Jodi is delighted to lend her voice and heart to Lost in Love, a celebration of love in all its forms. Her notable roles include the lead role in Annie (1979), Madame de la Grande Bouche (Beauty and the Beast), and Mrs. Silver. With a lifelong love of music and storytelling, Jodi brings warmth, experience, and emotion to every performance.

A devoted fan of Whitney Houston, Jodi draws inspiration from powerful vocals and songs that speak straight to the heart. When she’s not on stage, you can find her on YouTube or occasionally performing live at O’Reilly’s Pub in Newton.

Jodi lovingly dedicates this performance to her husband of 20 years, Mishka— her constant support, greatest love, and forever duet partner.

JOSH REED

<i>Emcee / Director</i>

Josh is excited to be part of Lost in Love, lending his voice to an evening devoted entirely to matters of the heart. His notable roles include Jake (Evil Dead: The Musical) and Scanlon (One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest), and he’s thrilled to explore a more intimate, music-driven setting with this cabaret.

A lover of all things purple, Josh would also like to invite audiences to come see Drama Geek Studios’ upcoming April production of 1984. He lovingly dedicates this performance to Kayla and Finn, whose love and support mean everything to him.

KAYLA D'ANGELO

<i>Performer</i>

Kayla is thrilled to be part of Lost in Love, celebrating passion, connection, and all the beautiful complexities of love through music. Her notable roles include Mary Magdalene (Jesus Christ Superstar), Linda and Annie (Evil Dead: The Musical), Ursula (The Little Mermaid), Penny Pingleton (Hairspray), Frank-N-Furter (The Rocky Horror Picture Show shadow cast), and Blind Mag (Repo! The Genetic Opera shadow cast).

In addition to performing, Kayla has directed shadow cast productions of The Rocky Horror Picture Show and Repo! The Genetic Opera, bringing her creativity and leadership to every corner of the theatrical world she inhabits.

Kayla lovingly dedicates this performance to Josh and Finn, whose love, support, and encouragement mean everything to her.

KENZIE MAYER

<i>Performer</i>

Kenzie is thrilled to be part of Lost in Love, bringing enthusiasm and joy to this celebration of music and connection. She previously appeared in her school's production of Frozen and is incredibly excited to continue growing as a performer.

The youngest of a set of triplets, Kenzie brings a unique spark and a big heart to the stage. She lovingly dedicates this performance to her family and friends, whose support and encouragement mean so much to her.

KEVIN W. CASEY

<i>Performer</i>

Kevin is excited to be part of Lost in Love, celebrating music, connection, and all the ways love shows up in our lives. His notable roles include Peter Pan, Home Alone: The Play, Guys and Dolls, The Addams Family, The Little Mermaid, Hairspray, Jesus Christ Superstar, The SpongeBob Musical, and Evil Dead: The Musical (Ensemble), as well as Ruckley in One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.

Offstage, Kevin is certified in Mental Health First Aid, CPR, and the Heimlich maneuver — proving he’s just as supportive behind the scenes as he is on stage. Known for always being there with a joke, Kevin brings levity, kindness, and heart wherever he goes.

He lovingly dedicates this performance to the memory of his girlfriend Shannan, her mom Anita, and his father Bill, whose love and laughter will always shine in Kevin's heart.

LARRY "DS" DARST

Larry “DS” is delighted to be part of Lost in Love, sharing his voice in this celebration of romance and connection. His notable roles include Bob Cratchit (A Christmas Carol), Dr. Spivey (One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest), and Jack Ross (A Few Good Men).

When he’s not on stage, Larry’s life is full — with four cats, two children, and one wife, all of whom keep him endlessly entertained and deeply loved.

Larry dedicates this performance to June Charlene Amato Darst, whose love is the constant melody behind every song he sings.

LOGAN SELLERS

<i>Performer</i>

Logan brings joy, charm, and heart to the Lost in Love stage. His notable roles include SpongeBob (The SpongeBob Musical), Jack Kelly (Newsies), Lumière (Beauty and the Beast), and Link Larkin (Hairspray). Logan recently made his New York City debut at 54 Below, a milestone he’s incredibly proud of and grateful for.

When he’s not performing, Logan enjoys sharing his journey online — you can follow along at @loganstheaterjourney on TikTok. Logan lovingly dedicates this performance to his family, friends, and his girlfriend Kaylee, whose support and love mean the world to him.

MACY O'SHEA

<i>Performer</i>

Macy is delighted to be part of Lost in Love, sharing her passion for storytelling through music. Her notable roles include Les (Newsies), Matilda (Matilda), the Mad Hatter (Alice in Wonderland), and Annie (Annie, Jr.)— with the unique honor of having played two titular roles on stage.

Macy has heterochromia (two different colored eyes) and also performs with the color guard, bringing both visual artistry and emotional depth to her performances.

She lovingly dedicates this performance to her family and friends, as well as her castmates, whose encouragement, camaraderie, and shared love of music make nights like this unforgettable.

MEG KOENIG

<i>Performer</i>

Meg is overjoyed to be back on stage with her theater family in Lost in Love after a long hiatus. Her notable roles include Miss Honey (Matilda), Lonny (Rock of Ages), the Baker’s Wife (Into the Woods), and Scuttle (The Little Mermaid), showcasing a range from heartfelt to hilarious.

Meg is thrilled to return to performing and reconnect with the joy that theatre brings. Fun fact: she can’t curl all her toes (she fully admits she’s a little weird — and proudly so!).

She lovingly dedicates this performance to her husband, Brian, her biggest supporter and forever Valentine.

NOAH RENALDO

<i>Performer</i>

Noah is excited to be part of Lost in Love, sharing music that celebrates connection, joy, and all the feelings in between. His notable roles include Jack Kelly (Newsies), Moose (Evil Dead: The Musical, Lord Farquaad (Shrek Jr.), and Kyle Mason (Finding J. Mitchell), each one reflecting his love for storytelling and performance.

A versatile musician, Noah plays the trumpet, guitar, and French horn, bringing a deep appreciation for music into everything he does. He will next be featured in Newton High School’s production of Shrek and can’t wait for what’s ahead.

Noah lovingly dedicates this performance to his mom, dad, and Adelyn, whose support, encouragement, and love mean the world to him.

SAM GARCIA

<i>Music Director / Performer</i>

Sam is thrilled to share the stage in Lost in Love, a cabaret devoted to songs of romance, longing, and connection. A familiar face with Drama Geek Studios, Sam has appeared in numerous productions, most notably as Lord Farquaad (Shrek), Sebastian (The Little Mermaid), Corny Collins (Hairspray) and Angel (Rent). In addition to performing, Sam has served as music director for multiple DGS productions, including this one, helping shape the sound and soul of countless shows.

Sam recently completed his Bachelor’s degree in Music Education at Rowan University, where he received extensive classical voice training and performed with the Opera Company in Susannah (Little Bat), Yeomen of the Guard (Leonard), and La Bohème (Featured Ensemble).

For Lost in Love, Sam is grateful to be surrounded by friends, collaborators, and fellow storytellers. He would like to dedicate this performance to his family, friends, and colleagues for supporting him, believing in him, and sharing in the journey — because love, after all, is better when it’s sung together.

STEVE JOHNSON

<i>Performer</i>

Steve is thrilled to be part of Lost in Love, celebrating music, connection, and a whole lot of heart. His notable roles include ensemble (Rock of Ages), Wilbur Turnblad (Hairspray), Peter (Jesus Christ Superstar), Patchy (The SpongeBob Musical), and the unforgettable Knowby & Killer Body (Evil Dead: The Musical).

A fun challenge for the audience: Steve has performed duets with three of his Lost in Love castmates — care to guess which ones? Steve has also only shared an onstage kiss with one of those castmates...we're sure you won't guess who it was! He also sends a special shout-out to his two biggest Patchy fans, who know exactly who they are.

Steve lovingly dedicates this performance to his parents, who first gave him his love for singing and theatre — a gift that continues to shape every note he sings.

TORRIE WILKINSON

<i>Performer</i>

Torrie is thrilled to make her Drama Geek Studios debut in Lost in Love. She previously performed as Elsa in Frozen Jr. and Grace Farrell in Annie Jr. with the Tampa Bay Performing Arts Academy, and is excited to bring her voice and heart to this special cabaret.

Outside of theatre, Torrie is a professional comic artist and enjoys playing recreational soccer. She also made the big move from Florida to New Jersey — a leap of faith fueled by courage, adventure, and a little bit of crazy!

Torrie lovingly dedicates this performance to her amazing and supportive mother, and to her love, Angelo, for always believing in her and cheering her on

Kelly Renaldo

<i>Lighting Operator</i>

Kelly may not be performing onstage in Lost in Love, but she is — as always — the heartbeat behind the curtain. If something needs to be done, found, fixed, or remembered, Kelly is already on it. Her steady presence, calm leadership, and endless care ensure that every moment onstage happens seamlessly.

Kelly has been an indispensable part of the Drama Geek Studios family, supporting performers and creatives alike with patience, kindness, and unwavering dedication. In a show devoted to love, connection, and vulnerability, Kelly represents the quiet, steadfast love that makes everything else possible. Kelly did actually appear in two DGS productions: she was ensemble in Jesus Christ Superstar and her first speaking role as Mrs. Fezziwig in A Christmas Carol (during this performance, Kelly also filled in one show as Mrs. Crachit! She vowed never again!)

She is grateful to be part of a community built on trust and creativity — and reminds us that some of the most important love stories happen just out of the spotlight.

Maddie DiDomenico

<i>Sound Operator</i>

Maddie is usually found under the stage lights, but for Lost in Love she’s spreading the love from the booth. A longtime member of the Drama Geek Studios family, Maddie has spent years bringing characters to life onstage — and this time, she’s helping the magic happen from behind the scenes.

Whether performing or working tech, Maddie’s heart for theatre and for this community shines through in everything she does. She’s thrilled to support this cabaret in a new way and to help ensure every love song lands just right. After all, some of the best love stories happen quietly, behind the curtain.

Kathy Reed

<i>Front of House Manager</i>

Kathy is the first smile audiences see and the steady presence that welcomes everyone into the world of Lost in Love. With warmth, grace, and a genuine love for this theatre, Kathy ensures that every guest feels at home from the moment they walk through the doors.

As the heart of the front of house, Kathy helps set the tone for an evening filled with music, connection, and romance. In a show devoted to love in all its forms, she reminds us that sometimes the simplest acts of kindness — a smile, a welcome, a helping hand — are the most meaningful of all.

Scott Dunkerley

<I>Usher</i>

Scott is happy to be part of Lost in Love, helping welcome audiences into an evening filled with music and romance. Typically found behind the scenes as part of the stage crew, Scott made his onstage debut this past November as Brian in One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest and is excited to continue supporting productions in every way he can.

Whether backstage, onstage, or greeting patrons at the door, Scott brings dedication and enthusiasm to the Drama Geek Studios family — proving that love for theatre comes in many forms

Lighting & Sound Design: Joshua Reed
Set Construction & Decoration: Joshua Reed, Drew Renaldo, Kelly Renaldo, Logan Sellers, & Noah Renaldo

Everyone you see onstage, behind the scenes, in the booth, and running the house is a volunteer. They devote countless hours to creating a safe, welcoming space where our community can come together to enjoy live theatre. We would like to extend our deepest thanks to all of you for your continued support of The Historic Crescent Theater and Drama Geek Studios. We truly couldn’t do this without you.

Special thanks to Jaime LeMelledo of Jamie Lynn Photography for capturing our beautiful headshots. Be sure to follow Jamie on Facebook and Instagram and support her incredible work.

Drama Geek Studios and The Historic Crescent Theater would also like to thank the local businesses who support us through promotion, patronage, and encouragement. Please remember to support small businesses and shop local whenever you can.

A very special thank you to Norwescap–Sussex Borough Community & Cultural Center for their continued support of our community and for providing assistance with promotional materials.

Thank you, our patrons, for being part of our story.

NEXT ON OUR STAGE:
1984 | April 10–19
Freedom. Truth. Love.
What happens when the state controls them all? Experience Orwell’s haunting dystopia brought to life in a gripping theatrical event.
 

ONE NIGHT ONLY… TWICE
THE EDGAR ALLAN POE SPEAKEASY
Stories & Macabre Cocktails
April 3 & 4 | Historic Crescent Theater
Step into the shadows for an immersive evening of Edgar Allan Poe’s chilling tales paired with carefully crafted, macabre cocktails. This adults-only speakeasy experience blends gothic storytelling, live performance, and darkly delightful drinks into one unforgettable night.

LET’S DO THE TIME WARP… AGAIN!
THE ROCKY HORROR PICTURE SHOW – SHADOW CAST
April 25 | Historic Crescent Theater
Grab your fishnets, warm up your callbacks, and join us for a wildly interactive night of cult-classic chaos. Virgin or veteran, this is one night you don’t want to miss.

Drama Geek Studios is a non-profit organization dedicated to producing diverse theatrical and cultural events that enrich the lives of our community and the broad region we serve, with education and  outreach programs for all ages, including training  programs,  play development and musicals. Drama Geek Studios is a fun, interactive learning environment  centered around the performing arts. We firmly believe that by  developing our creativity, fostering our individuality, and allowing  inspiration to be pursued, we become more productive people,  definitely more fun to be around, and more likely to make a  difference in our world.

Connect with Us: 

E-mail: dramageekstudios@gmail.com

Mailing Information: 

Drama Geek Studios

74 Main Street Sussex Boro, N.J. 07461

Guestbook